Want More Trust? Say ‘I Don’t Know’

In partnership with

What Top Execs Read Before the Market Opens

The Daily Upside was founded by investment professionals to arm decision-makers with market intelligence that goes deeper than headlines. No filler. Just concise, trusted insights on business trends, deal flow, and economic shifts—read by leaders at top firms across finance, tech, and beyond.

Join 1M+ professionals who stay informed before the rest of the market catches up.

In 1986, NASA launched the Challenger space shuttle.

Seventy-three seconds after liftoff, it exploded, broadcast live to millions around the world.

What followed was a deep investigation into the failure. It wasn’t just a technical error. It was a leadership one.

Multiple engineers had raised concerns about the O-ring seals in cold weather. But their voices were drowned out by deadlines, pressure, and a leadership culture where saying “I don’t know” felt like weakness.

It was a tragedy born not of ignorance, but of denial.

And it left a lasting leadership lesson in its wake:

Pretending to know is more dangerous than admitting you don’t.

Insecurity Disguised as Certainty

We’ve been trained to think the best leaders are decisive, confident, and quick to answer.

But many leaders confuse certainty with strength. They rush to provide answers—even when they shouldn’t. They fear saying “I don’t know” will cost them authority or respect.

In reality, the opposite is true.

The leaders we trust most don’t pretend. They pause. They ask. They explore.

They know leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about creating a space where the right answers can surface.

The Myth of the All-Knowing Leader

Let’s bust a myth: no one has all the answers in today’s world.

The pace of change is too fast. The complexity is too high. Technology, markets, and customer expectations shift daily.

So when leaders posture as experts on everything, two things happen:

1. The team stops contributing.
Why speak up if the leader already “knows”?

2. Mistakes get hidden.
When admitting uncertainty is punished, silence takes its place.

And that’s where the real risk begins, not in ignorance, but in the fear of exposing it.

Real Confidence Sounds Like This:

• “I don’t have that answer, yet. Let’s figure it out.”

• “What am I missing here?”

• “I trust your expertise. What do you see that I might not?”

• “Let’s get more data before we decide.”

These aren’t signs of weakness.

They’re signs of a confident, self-aware leader who doesn’t need to perform to earn trust.

Because leadership isn’t about being the smartest in the room.

It’s about being wise enough to unlock the intelligence around you.

The Hidden Power of Admitting What You Don’t Know

When leaders openly acknowledge gaps in knowledge, several powerful things happen:

1. Psychological Safety Increases

People feel safer speaking up. They’re more willing to challenge assumptions or bring forward risks, because the leader just modeled that not knowing is okay.

2. The Team Gets Smarter

The conversation becomes collaborative, not hierarchical. The group learns faster. Better ideas emerge. Silos break down.

3. Credibility Goes Up

Ironically, saying “I don’t know” makes people trust you more. Why? Because it signals honesty. And in high-stakes environments, nothing is more valuable than a leader who tells the truth, even when it’s inconvenient.

Why Most Leaders Struggle With This

There’s a reason this kind of humility is rare.

Because most leadership cultures reward certainty, not inquiry.

You’re expected to be decisive. Strong. Unshakable.

And so we build a culture where “I don’t know” feels like failure.

But here’s the truth:

Great leadership isn’t about having fewer questions. It’s about asking better ones.

What This Looks Like in Practice

Here’s how strong, humble leaders operate:

✅ They lead with curiosity, not control.

They don’t walk into meetings with fixed answers. They frame problems, ask questions, and invite others into the solution.

✅ They elevate voices that challenge them.

They don’t just tolerate dissent. They seek it out.

“Push back if I’m missing something” becomes a regular phrase in their vocabulary.

✅ They learn in public.

They read. They ask. They say, “I was wrong.”
They model what it looks like to grow, not just perform.

The Confidence Shift: From Knowing to Learning

The shift from all-knowing to always-learning is subtle, but transformative.

One creates a ceiling on team intelligence.
The other creates a multiplier effect.

One breeds fear.
The other builds trust.

And in a complex, fast-changing world, the second wins every time.

Lead with Curiosity, Earn with Credibility

It’s easy to fall into the trap of pretending to know.

But real leadership means holding space for uncertainty and showing your team that not knowing isn’t a flaw. It’s a starting point.

So the next time you’re unsure, resist the urge to fake it.

Pause. Ask. Invite.

Because you’re not paid to know everything.

You’re trusted to lead the process of figuring it out.

And in a world full of noise, the leader who says, “Let’s find the answer together,” builds something stronger than certainty:

A culture of trust, learning, and unstoppable growth.